Editorial Policies & Publication Ethics

Economic Development, Journal of Institute of Economics-Skopje

  

PEER REVIEW POLICY

All manuscripts submitted to the journal Economic Development undergo a double-blind peer review process to ensure academic quality, originality, and relevance to the scope of the Journal.

Each manuscript is evaluated by two independent reviewers who are experts in the relevant field. The identities of authors and reviewers are concealed throughout the review process.

Reviewers assess submissions based on the following criteria:

  • Scientific relevance and contribution to the field
  • Methodological soundness
  • Originality of the research
  • Clarity of presentation and structure
  • Appropriateness of references and engagement with relevant literature

Based on reviewers’ reports, the Editorial Board may reach one of the following decisions:

  • Accept without revisions
  • Accept with minor revisions
  • Revise and resubmit (major revisions required)
  • Reject

The final decision regarding publication rests with the Editor-in-Chief and the Editorial Board.

The Journal is committed to ensuring that the review process is fair, objective, confidential, and free from conflicts of interest. Reviewers who identify a conflict of interest must decline the review invitation.

Typical review time is between 2 and 4 weeks, depending on reviewer availability and the extent of revisions required.

 

AUTHORSHIP & CONTRIBUTIONS

The journal Economic Development adheres to internationally recognized standards of authorship and contributor responsibility.

Authorship should be limited to individuals who have made a significant intellectual contribution to the research. An author is expected to have participated in:

  • The conception or design of the study, or the acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of data
  • Drafting the manuscript or critically revising it for important intellectual content
  • Approving the final version of the manuscript prior to submission
  • Agreeing to be accountable for all aspects of the work and to ensure that questions related to the accuracy or integrity of any part of the work are appropriately investigated and resolved

All individuals who meet these criteria should be listed as authors. Individuals who contributed to the work but do not meet authorship criteria should be acknowledged appropriately.

The corresponding author is responsible for:

  • Ensuring that all listed co-authors have seen and approved the final manuscript
  • Confirming that no eligible contributor has been omitted
  • Managing communication with the Editorial Office during the submission and review process
  • Informing the Editorial Office of any proposed changes to authorship (order, addition, or removal of authors) prior to publication

Changes in authorship after submission must be justified and approved by the Editorial Board. All authors must provide written consent for such changes.

The Journal does not permit guest authorship, gift authorship, or ghost authorship. Any disputes regarding authorship will be handled according to the Journal’s Complaints & Appeals policy.

The journal encourages all authors to register and provide an ORCID ID to ensure accurate attribution of authorship and to improve the visibility and traceability of published research.

 

PLAGIARISM POLICY

The journal Economic Development maintains a strict policy against plagiarism and unethical reuse of published or unpublished material.

All submitted manuscripts are checked for similarity prior to peer review. The Editorial Board evaluates any potential similarities on a case-by-case basis, taking into account legitimate citations, references, and standard methodological descriptions, to ensure the integrity of the publication process.

 

Plagiarism includes, but is not limited to:

  • Copying text, ideas, data, or images from other sources without proper attribution
  • Substantial similarity to previously published work without appropriate citation
  • Self-plagiarism, including the reuse of significant parts of the author’s own published work without proper acknowledgment
  • Submission of a manuscript that is substantially similar to a previously submitted or published work

 

 

Duplicate Submission

The Journal does not permit duplicate submission. Manuscripts that are under consideration by another journal or have been submitted simultaneously elsewhere will be rejected. Authors must confirm that their work is not under review by any other publication at the time of submission.

If plagiarism, duplicate submission, or unethical text reuse is detected, the Journal may take one or more of the following actions:

  • Reject the manuscript
  • Request revisions with proper citation and correction
  • Inform the authors’ affiliated institutions
  • Retract a published article in accordance with the Journal’s Corrections & Retractions policy

The Journal follows recognized international standards of publication ethics in addressing cases of suspected plagiarism. Authors are responsible for ensuring that their work is original and that all sources are appropriately cited.

 

CONFLICTS OF INTEREST

The journal Economic Development is committed to ensuring transparency, objectivity, and integrity in the publication process. All participants in the editorial process-authors, reviewers, and editors-are required to disclose any conflicts of interest (COI) that could influence, or be perceived to influence, the evaluation, interpretation, or publication of scholarly work.

A conflict of interest may be financial or non-financial.

Conflicts of Interest-Authors

Authors must disclose any circumstances that could affect the interpretation of their research, including but not limited to:

Financial conflicts

  • Research funding, grants, or sponsorship
  • Employment, consultancy, or advisory roles
  • Ownership of shares, patents, or patent applications
  • Any financial benefit connected to the results of the research

Non-financial conflicts

  • Personal or professional relationships with individuals or institutions related to the manuscript
  • Academic competition or rivalry
  • Publicly expressed positions, advocacy roles, or ideological commitments that could be perceived to influence objectivity
  • Membership in organizations that may benefit from the publication of the research

All sources of funding must be clearly acknowledged in the manuscript.

Reviewers who identify a potential conflict of interest during the review process must immediately inform the Editorial Office and discontinue the review.

Conflicts of Interest – Editors

 

Editors should avoid handling manuscripts where potential conflicts of interest could affect their objectivity. Such situations may include personal or professional relationships with the authors, institutional affiliation, or financial or academic interests related to the manuscript. In such cases, the editorial responsibilities may be shared with or delegated to another member of the Editorial Board to ensure a fair evaluation process.

 

Manuscripts submitted by editors

 

If an editor submits a manuscript to the journal Economic Development:

 

  • The editor will not be solely responsible for the editorial decision on their manuscript
  • Another member of the Editorial Board will be involved in the review or decision process
  • The journal will take reasonable steps to ensure an independent and unbiased review
  • The role of the editor as an author may be disclosed in the published article where appropriate

 

The journal encourages transparency in declaring potential conflicts of interest. Failure to disclose relevant conflicts may be addressed in accordance with the journal’s editorial policies.

 

Mandatory Disclosure of Conflicts of Interest and Ethical Responsibilities

As part of the Journal’s commitment to transparency, integrity, and high ethical standards in scholarly publishing, authors and reviewers are required to submit formal declarations disclosing any relevant conflicts of interest and confirming their adherence to the Journal’s core ethical principles. Editors, while not required to submit a formal declaration, are expected to adhere strictly to the same standards of transparency, impartiality, and ethical responsibility in all aspects of the editorial process.

These requirements support fairness, objectivity, and trust in the evaluation and publication of scholarly work.

Authors

At the time of manuscript submission, authors must submit an Author Declaration on Conflict of Interest, Originality and Publication Ethics. This declaration formally confirms compliance with the Journal’s policies on conflicts of interest, originality of the manuscript, and adherence to core publication ethics principles.

 

Reviewers

Before accepting a review assignment, reviewers must complete a Reviewer Declaration on Conflict of Interest and Review Ethics. This declaration confirms their compliance with the Journal’s standards on impartiality, confidentiality, and ethical conduct in peer review.

Editors

Editors are expected to adhere strictly to the Journal’s policies on conflicts of interest and editorial ethics. Although editors do not submit a formal declaration, they are required to act in accordance with the same principles of transparency, impartiality, and integrity described in this policy.

 

RESEARCH DATA & REPRODUCIBILITY

The journal Economic Development supports transparency, integrity, and reproducibility in research and encourages practices aligned with the principles of open science. Authors are encouraged to ensure that the data underlying their findings are accurate, properly documented, and accessible where possible.

Data Availability

Research data are understood as materials associated with the research project. This may include raw or processed data files, software, algorithms, protocols, methods, questionnaires, and other supporting research materials.

The journal Economic Development encourages the responsible sharing of research data, where appropriate, in anonymized form and in accordance with applicable ethical, legal, and confidentiality considerations. Authors may choose to make their research data available through suitable and reliable data repositories that support long-term preservation, accessibility, and proper documentation of research materials.

The Journal does not host, publish, or manage research data directly.

When research data are cited in an article, authors should reference the dataset in the reference list using a recognized citation style, preferably the citation style recommended in the Journal’s Authors’ Guidelines.

If concerns arise regarding the authenticity or integrity of research data, reviewers and editors may request clarification from the authors, and such cases will be handled in accordance with the Journal’s Publication Ethics policies.

Reproducibility of Research

Authors are encouraged to provide sufficient methodological detail to allow other researchers to understand, evaluate, and, where feasible, replicate the study. This includes:

  • Clear description of research design and methods
  • Transparent reporting of data collection and analysis procedures
  • Disclosure of software, tools, or statistical methods used
  • Proper citation of datasets, instruments, or external resources
  • Ethical and Legal Considerations
  • The Journal recognizes that data sharing may be restricted in cases involving:
  • Personal or sensitive data
  • Confidential business or institutional information
  • Legal or contractual limitations

In such cases, authors should clearly state the nature of the restrictions and, where possible, indicate conditions under which data may be accessed.

Open Science

The journal Economic Development encourages authors to follow open science practices where appropriate, including transparency in research methods, sharing of research materials, and responsible data stewardship. The Journal supports initiatives that enhance reproducibility, accessibility, and the long-term value of scholarly research.

 

ETHICAL OVERSIGHT

The journal Economic Development is committed to upholding ethical standards in research and publication. Authors are expected to ensure that their research has been conducted in accordance with applicable ethical principles and relevant legal or institutional requirements.

Where research involves human participants, personal data, surveys, interviews, or other forms of direct interaction, authors should ensure that ethical considerations, including voluntary participation, informed consent where appropriate, and respect for privacy and confidentiality, have been observed.

The Journal may request clarification from authors if ethical concerns arise during the review or editorial process.

Failure to adhere to recognized ethical standards may result in rejection of the manuscript or, in serious cases, retraction of a published article in accordance with the Journal’s Corrections & Retractions policy.

 

COMPLAINTS & APPEALS POLICY

The journal Economic Development is committed to handling complaints and appeals in a fair, transparent, and timely manner.

Complaints

Complaints may relate to the editorial process, peer review, publication ethics, or the conduct of authors, reviewers, or editors. Complaints should be submitted in writing to the Editorial Office of the journal Economic Development via the official journal email, clearly stating the nature of the concern and providing any relevant supporting information.

All complaints will be reviewed by the Editor-in-Chief or a designated member of the Editorial Board. Where necessary, the Journal may consult additional editors or independent experts.

 

Appeals Against Editorial Decisions

Authors who wish to appeal an editorial decision must submit a written appeal to the Editorial Office, providing a clear justification and, where appropriate, a detailed response to the reviewers’ and editors’ comments.

Appeals will be evaluated by the Editor-in-Chief and, where appropriate, by members of the Editorial Board who were not involved in the original decision. The anonymity of reviewers will be maintained throughout the appeals process. The decision following an appeal is final.

Publication Ethics Complaints

Concerns regarding plagiarism, authorship disputes, conflicts of interest, data integrity, or other ethical issues will be handled in accordance with the Journal’s Publication еthics policies. The Journal may request additional information from the parties involved and, where appropriate, from their affiliated institutions.

The Journal reserves the right to take appropriate corrective actions, including rejection of a manuscript, publication of a correction, or retraction of a published article.

 

CORRECTIONS & RETRACTIONS

The journal Economic Development is committed to maintaining the accuracy and integrity of the scholarly record. When errors or ethical concerns are identified in published articles, the Journal will take appropriate corrective action.

Corrections

If a published article contains minor errors that do not affect the overall validity or conclusions of the work, the Journal may publish a correction notice. Authors may also request the publication of a correction if they identify an error in their published work. Corrections will clearly identify the original article and specify the changes made.

Retractions

A retraction may be issued in cases of serious ethical breaches or fundamental errors that invalidate the findings of the article. Reasons for retraction may include, but are not limited to:

  • Plagiarism or significant text duplication
  • Fabrication or falsification of data
  • Undisclosed conflicts of interest that affect the integrity of the research
  • Unethical research practices
  • Duplicate publication

Retraction notices will be clearly linked to the original article and will state the reason for the retraction. Retracted articles will remain accessible in the Journal archive but will be clearly marked as retracted.

 

 

Expressions of Concern

In cases where serious concerns have been raised but an investigation is still ongoing, the Journal may publish an expression of concern to inform readers.

Decisions regarding corrections, retractions, or expressions of concern are made by the Editor-in-Chief, in consultation with members of the Editorial Board where appropriate.

The Journal follows recognized international standards of publication ethics when handling corrections, retractions, or expressions of concern.

 

EDITORIAL INDEPENDENCE

The journal Economic Development ensures that editorial decisions are made independently and are based solely on academic merit, relevance to the scope of the Journal, and the quality of the research.

Although the Journal is published by the Institute of Economics-Skopje, editorial decisions are taken independently of the publisher’s administrative or institutional interests. The Editor-in-Chief and the Editorial Board act in their editorial capacity and are responsible for safeguarding the integrity of the peer review and publication process.

Editors and members of the Editorial Board are expected to act with integrity, impartiality, and confidentiality in all aspects of the editorial process. Any editor with a conflict of interest concerning a manuscript must recuse themselves from handling that submission.

Where the Editor-in-Chief or a member of the Editorial Board holds an institutional leadership position within the publisher, editorial responsibilities remain separate from institutional or administrative roles. In cases where a potential institutional conflict of interest may arise, the Editor-in-Chief will delegate the editorial handling of the manuscript to another qualified member of the Editorial Board.

Editorial responsibilities are separated from financial, administrative, or institutional influences to safeguard the objectivity of the Journal’s publication decisions. The Journal does not permit commercial, political, or institutional interests to influence editorial decisions.